Event · AD 156 · Phrygia — Pepuza and Tymion
The New Prophecy erupts, AD 156
The New Prophecy (Montanism) erupts in Phrygia
**The movement the archive holds by its own name for itself — the New Prophecy — rather than by the name its opponents gave it.**
Montanus began to prophesy in Phrygia, and with him **Priscilla and Maximilla**, who spoke in ecstasy and in the first person as the voice of the Spirit. The archive holds all three. They expected the heavenly Jerusalem at **Pepuza**, taught rigorous fasting, forbade remarriage, and welcomed martyrdom.
## The evidential problem, stated plainly
**Almost nothing survives from their side.** What the archive has is a handful of oracles quoted by hostile writers and preserved by Eusebius — including Maximilla’s **“I am driven away like a wolf from the sheep; I am not a wolf: I am word, and spirit, and power”**, and Montanus’s **“behold, man is as a lyre, and I fly to him as a plectrum”**.
**Those are quotations selected to condemn**, and the archive says so. It also notes what the opponents concede by accident: an anonymous writer in Eusebius admits he was asked to write and hesitated **for fear of seeming to add to the gospel**, and that the movement had to be met by councils of “the faithful” assembling repeatedly — **which is the first evidence in the archive of synods convened to settle a dispute.**
## Two things worth having
**Two of the three founders were women prophesying with authority**, and the objection recorded against them was not that they were women but that their ecstasy was involuntary and their predictions failed. The archive records the objection as made.
**And it captured Tertullian.** The most formidable Latin writer of the period joined them, and the archive holds his works — which means the movement is represented in the library by a sympathiser of great ability, even though its own founders are not.
The sources for this event
Every source the record rests on, with what it says and what it cannot carry.
Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History V.16–19
c. AD 325[Eusebius preserves the anonymous writer against the New Prophecy, and with him the only surviving words of its leaders. Maximilla: **“I am driven away like a wolf from the sheep; I am not a wolf: I am word, and spirit, and power.”** Montanus: **“behold, man is as a lyre, and I fly to him as a plectrum.”** ⚠ **These are quotations selected by opponents to condemn**, and nothing survives from the movement’s own hand. Two things the opponents concede by accident: the writer hesitated to write **for fear of seeming to add to the gospel**, and the faithful had to assemble in councils repeatedly to meet the movement — **the first evidence in this archive of synods convened to settle a dispute.**]
Eusebius, *Ecclesiastical History* — held in this library. English: A. C. McGiffert, NPNF 2nd ser. 1 (1890), public domain.
Read the source text →Figures in this event (5)
Scholarship
- Montanism: Gender, Authority and the New ProphecyChristine Trevett, 1996On the oracles, the women prophets, and the hostile transmission of all the evidence.